Home >> Community >> Opinion Archive
Register Now Free
Send real estate referrals here

Search properties

 

Business Directory Search

Latest Service Provider

SA Newsletter

Get the latest information about Mexico from the experts.
No account yet?

Opinion Archive

Print E-mail
Article Index
Opinion Archive
Two Cities
Bad Luck
Low Expectations
Fixing Elections
Spoiled Parties
Mexico and Latin America
Mexico's Garish LImelight
Wealth
Apocalypticism
Helping the War Effort
Social Cannon Fodder
Collective Wisdom
Relative Strength
Vigilantes
(My) Crisis Generation
FCH and BHO in DC
Civil War
Mexico and Ayn Rand
Mexico 2009
Energy
Foolish Forbes
Nations Character
Living in Mexico City
Mafias in Mexico
Gobernacion
Obama and Mexico
2008-2012
Panic of 2008
Social Mobility
Candidates' Silence on Immigration
New Malaise
Financial Confidence Tricks
Dual Citizenship
Conspiracy Theories
American Example
Mexican Gun Laws
Peaceniks and Warmongers
Security Dysfunction II
Never Ending Conflicts
Security Dysfunction
Public Lies and Innuendo
Europe and Mexico
Economic Self-Sabotage
Mexican Worker
1776 and Mexico
Cancun vs Miami
Ethics in Journalism
Odd, but Hopeful Election
Protests in a Democracy
Worst Case Scenario
Dearth of Energy Leadership
Real Estate Market
Tijuana
Mexicos Wealthy Exiles
Government by Simulation
Our Similarities
Our Differences
Mexicos Diverse States
Panama as a Latin Hong Kong
Calderons First Big Mistake
Anti-NAFTA Populism
AMLO Post-2006
Cuba
Energy Debate Farce
Calderon goes to America
"Securing the Border First"
Urban Blight
The Hate Profession
American Honest Broker
"Browning" of America
Mexico 2008
Narco-Violence
The Angry Left
International Relations
Mexican Freedom
Texas and Mexico
Environmentalism
Mexico City
Gulf Coast Disasters
The Merida Initiative
Mexico, circa 2007

 

What to Make of Mexico and Ayn Rand

January 7, 2009

One of the first sub-plots in Ayn Rand's magnum opus, "Atlas Shrugged" occurs in the fictitious "People's State of Mexico". Nationalizations there are harbingers of collectivization schemes that begin happening in Rand's dystopian USA. In the novel, this tendency to reward prebendalism (a type of crony-based corruption), while punishing creativity, eventually leads to the self-imposed exile of the captains of industry who make things happen. These people represent the proverbial Atlas who carries the world on his shoulders. When Atlas "shrugs", the Earth collapses. "Atlas Shrugged" is an intelligent and entertaining, if simplistic, chronicle of what happens when the "doers" don't.


This column is not an Objectivist (Rand's philosophy) manifesto, nor is the author an Ayn Rand apologist. If nothing else, the current economic downturn has put paid to the idea of "enlightened self-interest" requiring no fetters. For many during the go-go years of the beginning of the century, laissez-faire was a fancy French word for wealth-destroying greed. But, beyond the fact that "Atlas Shrugged" is an elegantly-written novel, Ms. Rand had an insight, or two, to share with her fellow humans. This insight does not make her "evil", as leftist Noam Chomsky branded her. Nor is it intellectually "stillborn", as Conservative William F. Buckley said in the obituary he wrote about her. It is profoundly simple: in all of human labor, people can either create, or destroy. What side are you on?


As we begin this new year, chastened by the financial destruction wrought by charlatans on Wall Street, Mexicans should spare a moment to think of those who destroy our well-being right here. There are the violent criminals, of course, but there are also many more who, just like in "Atlas Shrugged", wrap themselves in the discourse of "social justice" to make demands that are anything but "just".


Crucially, there is a fundamental difference between helping someone in need and allowing Mafia-style interest groups to get privileges that go against meritocracy. Most public-sector unions fit this bill. Knowing that they strike fear in politicians' hearts, they blackmail the government into giving bosses unsupervised public financing and allowing them to treat jobs in education and PEMEX (among others) as their private fiefdoms. Political parties, with their opacity and anti-democratic self-government, are probably starting to cross the line into anti-social territory, as well.


Everywhere you see people defending privileges that punish productivity and fight competition, be wary. There are many victims in this society, but very few of them are marching down Reforma (victims of crime excepted). Even when we help the disadvantaged, Mexicans have the nasty habit of perpetuating a debilitating sense of victimhood. This is a byproduct of centuries of overt paternalism on behalf of political strongmen and it is perhaps the biggest danger to the proper functioning of the country's democracy. Mexico needs to transit from this type of clientelism to a system based on empowering the individual to fend for him/herself after they have been helped. Nowhere does this change need to take place more quickly than in our indigenous communities, where fear, ignorance, and misguided "white man's burden" do-goodism have squashed opportunities for generations. Lifestyles based on ancestral cultures need to be chosen freely and intelligently; they should not be imposed by manipulative "chiefs" and romantic patronizing whites with utopian ideals of the "noble savage". Something to think about when you ponder the 70s retro "Zapatista" rebellion of 15 years ago.


Ayn Rand's principle mistake was, perhaps, a product of having watched the Bolsheviks in her native Russia destroy her family when she was 12. When you read one of the heroes in "Atlas Shrugged" proudly declare that "he would never live his life for the sake of another man", you know she's gone too far. In fact, some of the best and most productive people in the world live their lives solely for the sake of others. Further, her tendency to depict bureaucrats as caricatures of social parasites is also misguided: a good public servant can easily be the equal of a good captain of industry. The question is whether someone works to help empower others for the benefit of society, or whether their "help" is really a tool to build their own fame, fortune and power. Mexico's insidious ignorance means that too few people know how to tell the difference.


So, pick up "Atlas Shrugged" ("La rebelión de Atlas", in Spanish), read it, and give copies to your closest "radical chic" friends (those who are toasting the anniversary of the Cuban Revolution with champagne). Then ask yourself, are you Atlas, carrying the world on your hard-working shoulders? Or are you James Taggart, seeking to live off the work and ideas of others?

 

For the latest thought-provoking article by Agustin Barrios Gomez please go to our Opinion Column page

 

Return to top



 
< Prev   Next >

Other Articles

 
<<  1 2  >  >>


Warning: in_array() [function.in-array]: Wrong datatype for second argument in /home/emexpert/public_html/modules/mod_realestate_contents.php on line 125

Warning: in_array() [function.in-array]: Wrong datatype for second argument in /home/emexpert/public_html/modules/mod_realestate_contents.php on line 125

Warning: in_array() [function.in-array]: Wrong datatype for second argument in /home/emexpert/public_html/modules/mod_realestate_contents.php on line 125

Warning: in_array() [function.in-array]: Wrong datatype for second argument in /home/emexpert/public_html/modules/mod_realestate_contents.php on line 125

Warning: in_array() [function.in-array]: Wrong datatype for second argument in /home/emexpert/public_html/modules/mod_realestate_contents.php on line 125

Warning: in_array() [function.in-array]: Wrong datatype for second argument in /home/emexpert/public_html/modules/mod_realestate_contents.php on line 125

Warning: in_array() [function.in-array]: Wrong datatype for second argument in /home/emexpert/public_html/modules/mod_realestate_contents.php on line 125

Warning: in_array() [function.in-array]: Wrong datatype for second argument in /home/emexpert/public_html/modules/mod_realestate_contents.php on line 125

Warning: in_array() [function.in-array]: Wrong datatype for second argument in /home/emexpert/public_html/modules/mod_realestate_contents.php on line 125
 Guest Blogger -... Blog - Artist c... Latest Event of... Agustin's Lates...
 Expatriate of t... Event of the Mo... Charities in Me... Clubs and Assoc...
 Sam Speaks

Service Request

Most viewed articles Upcoming events
No Events Available
Lastest news

Warning: mysql_fetch_array(): supplied argument is not a valid MySQL result resource in /home/emexpert/public_html/modules/mod_advertise.php on line 46
Recent Classified Ads