Home >> Community >> Opinion Archive
Register Now Free
Send real estate referrals here

Search properties

 

Business Directory Search

Latest Service Provider

SA Newsletter

Get the latest information about Mexico from the experts.
No account yet?

Opinion Archive

Print E-mail
Article Index
Opinion Archive
Two Cities
Bad Luck
Low Expectations
Fixing Elections
Spoiled Parties
Mexico and Latin America
Mexico's Garish LImelight
Wealth
Apocalypticism
Helping the War Effort
Social Cannon Fodder
Collective Wisdom
Relative Strength
Vigilantes
(My) Crisis Generation
FCH and BHO in DC
Civil War
Mexico and Ayn Rand
Mexico 2009
Energy
Foolish Forbes
Nations Character
Living in Mexico City
Mafias in Mexico
Gobernacion
Obama and Mexico
2008-2012
Panic of 2008
Social Mobility
Candidates' Silence on Immigration
New Malaise
Financial Confidence Tricks
Dual Citizenship
Conspiracy Theories
American Example
Mexican Gun Laws
Peaceniks and Warmongers
Security Dysfunction II
Never Ending Conflicts
Security Dysfunction
Public Lies and Innuendo
Europe and Mexico
Economic Self-Sabotage
Mexican Worker
1776 and Mexico
Cancun vs Miami
Ethics in Journalism
Odd, but Hopeful Election
Protests in a Democracy
Worst Case Scenario
Dearth of Energy Leadership
Real Estate Market
Tijuana
Mexicos Wealthy Exiles
Government by Simulation
Our Similarities
Our Differences
Mexicos Diverse States
Panama as a Latin Hong Kong
Calderons First Big Mistake
Anti-NAFTA Populism
AMLO Post-2006
Cuba
Energy Debate Farce
Calderon goes to America
"Securing the Border First"
Urban Blight
The Hate Profession
American Honest Broker
"Browning" of America
Mexico 2008
Narco-Violence
The Angry Left
International Relations
Mexican Freedom
Texas and Mexico
Environmentalism
Mexico City
Gulf Coast Disasters
The Merida Initiative
Mexico, circa 2007

What to Make of the New Malaise

October 8, 2008

In 1979 President Jimmy Carter spoke to his country about a "crisis of confidence". Despite never having mentioned the word, this came to be known as the "malaise" speech. Malaise is a word from the French meaning "a general sense of depression, or unease". Then, as now, oil prices were too high and Americans felt that the country was going "in the wrong direction." Then, as now, the country was in a funk.


Mexico is also feeling down. Over the last few weeks even those columnists who are generally more sanguine, like Reyes Heroles and Silva-Herzog Márquez, have sounded more worried. In the US, people are depressed about the economy, while Mexicans are in shock over the escalation of violence, including our first terrorist act of the new millennium. In both places, there is a sense that all is not well.


The national "mood" affects much of what we do. The successful Sinaloan professional isn't going to invest in a new business in Culiacán if there's a drive-by shooting on his doorstep. The middle manager in Peoria isn't going to take out a mortgage to buy a house if he feels that his job is in jeopardy. The national mood can even make you give up on your country. Your correspondent has recently spent time in the suburbs of Houston and the number of Mexican yuppies fleeing from Mexico's crime by moving to Texas is a tragic sign of how depression can turn into total resignation.


But often the national mood is just another manifestation of the cycles that are present in everything around us. There are moments of "irrational exuberance" that lead to booms and "crises of confidence" that lead to busts. These moods are often independent of the actual pressures on society. The sense of mission and unity shown during World War II, for example, kept the national mood "high" despite the tremendous sacrifices that were being made. Today, people are as rich as they have ever been and the planet is generally peaceful, but people are living with an uncomfortable sense of dread.


In 1979 President Carter asked his country to look inward and stop worshipping "self-indulgence". He said that Americans had "discovered that owning things and consuming things does not satisfy our longing for meaning". But self-criticism needs leadership to provide an outlet for the pent up energy that is the fruit of our frustration. It is very possible that the global middle class is living beyond way beyond its means. But it is not enough to tell it so, there has to be a plan.

Man without a plan

President Carter failed to communicate a purpose. Hence, Ronald Reagan beat Jimmy Carter in 44 states during the 1980 elections. Candidate Reagan didn't offer a sophisticated plan, per se, but he did talk about a new dawn. "It's morning in America", he told them, and the country responded with a collective "hey, maybe he's right". In the year 2000, Vicente Fox told Mexicans to believe in themselves and kick the PRI out of office. But, devoid of the institutional infrastructure that gives continuity to the American system, Mr. Fox could not materialize his good intentions. Today, President Calderón's high-quality speeches give the Executive much-needed gravitas, but he is failing to convince Mexicans that he can win the war he has gotten them into.


In both countries, we have yet to see leadership that links the insight of a Jimmy Carter with the fresh-faced optimism of a Vicente Fox and the execution of a Michael Bloomberg. But national moods have a way of pulling 180s. During the Salinas regime, Mexicans came to believe that Mexico was well on its way to being a fully developed "first world" nation. During the 1950s, a time when Americans were much poorer and their minorities much more oppressed, technology held out the promise of an ever-better future. It was a promise that people wholeheartedly believed.


Of course, the future ain't what it used to be. But with a little effort and leadership, we can get back our collective chutzpah. President Kennedy set forth a cool challenge in the 1960s to get to the moon within ten years. Why not do the same thing for carbon emissions and global warming? Mexico's Calderón could offer to eradicate corruption in the 4 years left of his term, with serious oversight, penalties and incentives. While we're at it, we could reduce cruelty to animals for good karmic measure. That's something both countries could do as we fight the obesity and junk food epidemic.


Whatever the priority, the national mood needs a little leadership Prozac. Unfortunately, it doesn't look like our doctors know how to prescribe the right medicine. Let's offer them some suggestions.


 

For the latest thought-provoking article by Agustin Barrios Gomez please go to our Opinion Column page

 

Return to top



 
< Prev   Next >

Other Articles

 

SA Most
Popular Forums

SolutionsAbroad Mexico - General Discussion
(1 forums, 6 topics, 0 replies)
Retiring in Mexico
(5 forums, 15 topics, 13 replies)
Real estate experiences in Mexico
(5 forums, 6 topics, 4 replies)
Living in Mexico
(6 forums, 5 topics, 3 replies)
>More 

Top Blogs

  1. Ready to start playing: 
  2. Mexico's Shaky Road to the World Cup: 

    Two Mexicans make it into the YouTube Symphony Orchestra: 


>More 

Events

Festival Internacional Ce...

The Festival Cervantino in the colonial city of Guanajuato

The Morelia International...

The Morelia Int

AMERICAN SOCIETY OF MEXIC...


THE AMERICAN SOCIETY OF MEXICO, A.C.

Invite

>More 

Related Articles

Service Request